21 November 2026 – Saturday
21 November 2026 – Saturday

Shaping History Through Art: How Museums Define the Past

The way museums choose to display art does more than just preserve the past; it shapes the way people learn to see it. A museum’s cultural authority often dictates who gets to claim that piece of history, with the question most often presented as “all of us, or just them?” Through that authority, museums do not simply preserve art, but influence how history itself is understood. 

Most modern museums have a cosmopolitan atmosphere surrounding them. No matter which country they are in, they tend to display objects from all around the world. On a surface level, this can make it seem as though collective culture and history are being celebrated. However, few people stop to question how these “exotic” pieces ended up in these museums in the first place. The Benin Bronzes are one of the most famous examples of this process, as these works were not willingly given up by locals, but rather seized through violence. Once brought to Europe, they were absorbed into several museum systems and presented as objects of artistic and historical value, reframed as part of a shared past, although they were, in reality, evidence of colonial expansion. The issue is not only that these works were stolen from their rightful owners, but also that public opinion was shaped to see museums as doing humanity a service, as if they were bringing people together rather than benefitting from theft.  

Once stolen objects enter the museum, the setting itself is curated in a way that helps transform them from evidence of colonial violence into symbols of culture, education, and prestige. Behind carefully told stories and written labels lie works that were once among a nation’s most treasured possessions. Removed from their original context, these works get rebranded as pieces of human heritage and history rather than as products of coercion and loss. As people line up to admire them, awe often replaces questioning, and the history of violence becomes easier to overlook. In that process, the people and cultures these works belonged to get pushed into the background. What remains visible is nothing but the museum’s version of the object, not the world from which it was taken. In this way, museums do not merely showcase history, but a much more complex and often cruel system. 

This system does not entirely belong to the past, because many museums still hold authority over whether stolen works are returned and under what conditions. Even when the theft is acknowledged, the problem is far from over. Getting these works returned is rarely simple, because the process of asking for these objects back is slow, tedious and overall, a bureaucratic nightmare. The burden often falls on the people who were dispossessed to prove why these objects should come home. The case of the Benin Bronzes shows how unequal this process is, since some have been returned, but many others remain tied up in negotiations, conditions, and institutional delay. Part of what makes this specific case so drawn out is that the works are scattered across different museums and countries, each with its own willingness to cooperate. Nigeria, the home of the Benin Bronzes, has been asking for their return for years; yet even that long-standing demand has not led to full or immediate action on the museums’ part. As long as institutions can still decide how, when, or even whether the stolen objects get to be returned, colonial power has not ended; it has merely become administrative. 

What museums preserve is never just art. It is also power, the power to dictate what history looks like, who gets represented by it, and who owns it. When stolen works are displayed as if their presence is a service to humanity, but returned only through delay and negotiations, museums reveal that they are not neutral spaces at all. They do not simply protect the past, but also protect the idea that colonial ownership of art is somehow natural. 

defne.tokdemir@studbocconi.it | + posts

Hi everyone! My name is Defne and I'm a BIG student at Bocconi. I'm interested in culture and politics, especially how they combine and shape our daily lives. Additionally, I have a passion for writing in order to connect academic research with journalism. I hope to be able to pursue this professionally in the future.

share

Let’s dive into the world of creativity with a curated selection of stories spanning art, exhibitions, music, cinema, literature, and more. From timeless masterpieces to the latest cultural phenomena, Arts & Culture explores how the arts shape society and spark dialogue.

Every week on Wednesday.

Suggested articles

In Caravaggio’s Narcissus, a young man bends over a pool of water, captivated by his own reflection. More than four centuries later, the painting prompts a different kind of reflection, this time in Potenza,…
Può apparire superfluo parlare di antica Grecia in un mondo in cui regna sovrana la tecnologia e il suo progresso, in cui tutto è così dinamico e in continua evoluzione. Eppure, dovremmo soffermarci a…
Ore 23:45, l’aria si è fatta fredda e il cielo non promette nulla di buono. Sono con un mio amico, siamo in macchina a fumare l’ultima sigaretta nel parcheggio della chiesetta vicino a casa…

Trending

“A classic is a book which has never exhausted all it has to say to its readers” wrote Italo Calvino, ironically a writer who has since become a classic himself. Have you ever wondered…
Before factories became symbols of progress, they were intrusions on nature and society. Landscapes shaped by agriculture and small communities were cut through by railways and consumed by expanding cities. Work changed with them….
Look around.   Your phone is a black rectangle. Your laptop is a slightly larger black rectangle. Your car is probably white, black, or grey and, most likely, closely resembles the one parked next to…